La ricerca accademica sul web
Google Scholar
The Scholar revolution
The launch of Google Scholar in 2004 was a real paradigm shift in the information landscape. Unlike traditional bibliographic databases, Scholar presented itself as an open repository based not on the indexing of articles from journals selected by experts, but on the crawling of the whole web.
In this sense we can say that:
- It's dynamic: in the sense that the response to the query varies with what is available on the web in a given time
- It is able to cover every kind of publication, language, discipline
- It gives great importance to Open Access literature, indexing all those open archives that the scientific community has made available on the web in recent years, both institutional repositories (like our BOA) and disciplinary ones.
- Does not distinguish between peer-reviewed literature and not, so it is up to the researcher to assess the quality of the source
How Scholar works
The documents it stores in its index must have a URL, must not exceed 5MB (there are exceptions, but in these cases, the full text is not indexed) and must have technical and placement characteristics on the web pages such that they can be identified as "most likely academic". There are some errors sometimes since the procedure is entrusted to software and not to human beings, but overall they are quite rare.
Scholar's coverage has been continuously increasing since 2004. It cannot be expressed in a precise number either because it is dynamic or because Google does not make it public. However, attempts1 have been made to estimate it based on a set of parameters and cross queries and it is believed to be around 350-400 million documents, considering both the "source" documents and the references found in them.
It is, therefore, a very wide coverage indeed. At the moment we are writing (2020) the widest coverage compared to the competing archives and engines that are: Web of Science, Scopus, Microsoft Academic, Dimensions, Open Citation COCI, CiteSeerX, ResearchGate, Lens.org, Semantic Web, Scienstein.
Let's take a quick look at its features in this video.
1 As for the coverage of Scholar see in particular this contribution, other references are listed in the bibliography of the tutorial
Summary of the video
- It is important to learn how to use Scholar correctly when we are off Campus.
- From the settings in the three lines at the top left, select Links to libraries, search for Bicocca and Acnp and check them both. You will find out many more downloadable articles because Scholar automatically checks the Library holdings. A further step is searching Scholar directly in Prometeo, in this case, we rely on the Proxy server and therefore we must log in with Campus credentials, now the control over the Library holdings is complete.
- For searches that we do not want to be influenced by the history of our previous searches, it is good to open an incognito window.
- The most important factors in determining the ranking on the results page are the number of citations received and the relevance of the query to the title, the impact of full text and date is lower.
- The methods of refinement of the results offered are the "Cited by" on which you can make a further search, and the "related articles"
- Finally, you have the chance to save a record in your personal folder or export it to any reference manager.